Take Back Santa Cruz

Advocating for a Safe and Clean Santa Cruz

  • About
  • Get Involved
  • Blog
    • Latest Articles
    • In the Press
  • Resources
    • Storm Resources
    • Bike Theft/Registration
    • Cal Trans
    • City of Santa Cruz
    • County of Santa Cruz
    • Needles in Public Spaces
  • Events
  • SHOP
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Needles in Public Places / Home Is Where the Data Is: The County and the “evidence” used to stifle community discussion on the Syringe Service Program

Home Is Where the Data Is: The County and the “evidence” used to stifle community discussion on the Syringe Service Program

November 12, 2017 by TBSC Leave a Comment

Written by a Public Health Researcher at the request of the Needles Solutions Team

Supervisor “check your cynicism” Leopold feels that the public should not question the syringe service program (SSP) that is administered by the County Health Services Administration because it is “evidence-based”. The term “evidence-based” apparently says it all and no more discussion should be necessary from the common folk.

But what exactly is the “evidence”?

The evidence in “evidence-based” comes from research and although systematic reviews of studies, which might also include a quantitative component known as meta-analysis, have found methodological weaknesses and bias in the research on syringe service programs [1,2], there is general consensus of the obvious fact that using a clean syringe prevents the spread of disease.

But, the evidence is one-sided.

The evidence is only as useful as the research questions asked. According to one researcher who conducted a meta-analysis of research on syringe service programs, most of the studies primarily focus on information essential to demonstrate SSP effectiveness to funding sources and/or governmental units [2].  Thus, the primary focus of research on syringe programs is on benefits to people who inject drugs (PWIDs) with little or no mention of any adverse effects on the communities in which syringe programs are found.

And, few studies focus on effects of SSPs on communities where they are located.

It would be helpful if, in response to members of the public who voice concerns about the syringe service program housed at the County Health building, Supervisor Leopold would cite “evidence” from studies that look at the effect of SSPs on the community. Very few studies exist and it would be very helpful if Supervisor Leopold could locate and present these studies to the concerned public.

The studies have methodological shortcomings.

In his response to the Grand Jury report regarding the Santa Cruz County syringe service program, Dr. Arnold Leff cites a study that compared the prevalence of improperly discarded syringes in a city with SSPs (San Francisco) to one without SSPs (Miami) [3]. Although, the researchers found a higher prevalence of improperly discarded syringes in Miami, the limitations and methodological shortcomings of this study are numerous. The researchers admit that data was obtained in two different years, in 2008 in San Francisco, and 2009 in Miami. To count discarded syringes, the researchers conducted visual inspection walkthroughs of census blocks. However, in San Francisco, only one side of each randomly selected census block was inspected as compared to 4 sides of each selected census block in Miami. The researchers “mathematically adjusted” for this difference by multiplying the number of discarded syringes found in San Francisco by four. The authors of this study admit that they cannot generalize their results to other areas of each city, where behavior of PWIDs might differ.

The Needles Solutions Team has collected data but the County HSA does not consider it to be “evidence.”

Why does Dr. Leff cite a study with methodological shortcomings and issues of generalizability when we have data that was gathered in Santa Cruz County? If Supervisor Leopold and Dr. Leff care so much about evidence, why do they downplay evidence that was collected here? For over 4 and one-half years, the TBSC Needles Solution Team has carefully documented over 15,000 discarded syringes found in public. This is evidence!

Why does the Santa Cruz County SSP refuse to label the syringes they dispense even though such marking would help with research? In fact, one study, conducted in San Francisco, put color bands on syringes dispensed at exchanges so that the researchers could track them [4]. The researchers found that half of all marked syringes returned within two-weeks of being dispensed and 61% returned within the study period. The researchers also found that the rate of return of syringes varied between stationary syringe program sites and roving syringe program sites. It would be nice to obtain this kind of data right here in Santa Cruz, especially considering mobile syringe service is a local topic of discussion.

If Supervisor Leopold and Dr. Leff care so much about evidence, let’s start by working together to gather and interpret evidence where it’s highly applicable to our community, right here in Santa Cruz County.


References

[1] Fernandes, R. M., Cary, M., Duarte, G., Jesus, G., Alarcão, J., Torre, C., Carneiro, A. V. (2017). Effectiveness of needle and syringe Programmes in people who inject drugs – An overview of systematic reviews. BMC Public Health, 17, 309. http://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-017-4210-2

 [2] Ksobiech, Kate. (2004). Assessing and improving needle exchange programs: gaps and problems in the literature. Harm Reduction Journal 20041:4

[3] Tookes, H. E., Kral, A. H., Wenger, L. D., Cardenas, G. A., Martinez, A. N., Sherman, R. L., Metsch, L. R. (2012). A comparison of syringe disposal practices among injection drug users in a city with versus a city without needle and syringe programs. Drug and Alcohol Dependence, 123(1-3), 255–259.

[4]  Joseph Guydish, PhD, MPH, Geoge Clark Delia Garcia, Moher Downing, Patricia Case, and James L. Sorensen, PhD. (1991). Evaluating Needle Exchange: Do Distributed Needles Come Back? American Journal of Public Health; May 1991, Vol. 81, No. 5 (pp. 617-619)

Share Button

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Share on Facebook Share
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Pinterest Share
Share on LinkedIn Share
Share on Digg Share

Filed Under: Editorial, Needles in Public Places

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

<h3>Comments Rules of The Road</h3><h2>Please follow these rules when commenting on our site or Facebook page:</h2> <h3><strong>Be relevant</strong></h3> <p>Discuss the story and stay on topic.</p> <h3><strong>Be respectful</strong></h3> <p>Keep things civil. Avoid abusive or offensive language, threats, hate speech, libels and calls for violence. And please, don’t make jokes about the misfortune of others. Imagine it was your loved one in the story and show some restraint.</p> <h3><strong>Be honest</strong></h3> <p>Use your real name. Don’t post commercial messages. Don’t publish copyrighted material that belongs to someone else.</p> <h3><strong>Be discreet</strong></h3> <p>Don’t publish telephone numbers, addresses or other personal information about yourself or others.</p> <h3><strong>Be responsible</strong></h3> <p> </p> <h2>Commenting terms of use</h2> <p>Commenting is a privilege that will be revoked for violations of our terms of use. Inappropriate comments may be deleted. Users who violate the rules will be banned from commenting, perhaps with their previous comments deleted.</p> <p>Users are solely responsible for what they post and can be held responsible for violations of the law. Take Back Santa Cruz cannot verify the content of comments and does not vouch for their accuracy.</p> <div style="padding-bottom:20px; padding-top:10px;" class="hupso-share-buttons"><!-- Hupso Share Buttons - http://www.hupso.com/share/ --><a class="hupso_toolbar" href="http://www.hupso.com/share/"><img src="https://i0.wp.com/static.hupso.com/share/buttons/share-medium.png?ssl=1" style="border:0px; padding-top:5px; float:left;" alt="Share Button" data-recalc-dims="1"/></a><script type="text/javascript">var hupso_services_t=new Array("Twitter","Facebook","Google Plus","Tumblr","StumbleUpon","Digg","Reddit","Email","Print");var hupso_background_t="#EAF4FF";var hupso_border_t="#66CCFF";var hupso_toolbar_size_t="medium";var hupso_image_folder_url = "";var hupso_url_t="";var hupso_title_t="Home Is Where the Data Is: The County and the "evidence" used to stifle community discussion on the Syringe Service Program";</script><script type="text/javascript" src="https://static.hupso.com/share/js/share_toolbar.js"></script><!-- Hupso Share Buttons --></div><div class="sharedaddy sd-sharing-enabled"><div class="robots-nocontent sd-block sd-social sd-social-icon sd-sharing"><h3 class="sd-title">Share this:</h3><div class="sd-content"><ul><li class="share-twitter"><a rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" data-shared="sharing-twitter-3269" class="share-twitter sd-button share-icon no-text" href="https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/?share=twitter" target="_blank" title="Click to share on Twitter" ><span></span><span class="sharing-screen-reader-text">Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)</span></a></li><li class="share-facebook"><a rel="nofollow noopener noreferrer" data-shared="sharing-facebook-3269" class="share-facebook sd-button share-icon no-text" href="https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/?share=facebook" target="_blank" title="Click to share on Facebook" ><span></span><span class="sharing-screen-reader-text">Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)</span></a></li><li class="share-end"></li></ul></div></div></div> <div id='jp-relatedposts' class='jp-relatedposts' > <h3 class="jp-relatedposts-headline"><em>Related</em></h3> </div><div class='apss-social-share apss-theme-1 clearfix ' > <div class='apss-facebook apss-single-icon'> <a rel='nofollow' title="Share on Facebook" target='_blank' href='https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/'> <div class='apss-icon-block clearfix'> <i class='fab fa-facebook-f'></i> <span class='apss-social-text'>Share on Facebook</span> <span class='apss-share'>Share</span> </div> </a> </div> <div class='apss-twitter apss-single-icon'> <a rel='nofollow' href="https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=Home%20Is%20Where%20the%20Data%20Is%3A%20%20The%20County%20and%20the%20%22evidence%22%20used%20to%20stifle%20community%20discussion%20on%20the%20Syringe%20Service%20Program&url=https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/&" title="Share on Twitter" target='_blank'> <div class='apss-icon-block clearfix'> <i class='fab fa-twitter'></i> <span class='apss-social-text'>Share on Twitter</span><span class='apss-share'>Tweet</span> </div> </a> </div> <div class='apss-pinterest apss-single-icon'> <a rel='nofollow' title="Share on Pinterest" href='javascript:pinIt();'> <div class='apss-icon-block clearfix'> <i class='fab fa-pinterest'></i> <span class='apss-social-text'>Share on Pinterest</span> <span class='apss-share'>Share</span> </div> </a> </div> <div class='apss-linkedin apss-single-icon'> <a rel='nofollow' title="Share on LinkedIn" target='_blank' href='http://www.linkedin.com/sharing/share-offsite/?url=https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/'> <div class='apss-icon-block clearfix'><i class='fab fa-linkedin'></i> <span class='apss-social-text'>Share on LinkedIn</span> <span class='apss-share'>Share</span> </div> </a> </div> <div class='apss-digg apss-single-icon'> <a rel='nofollow' title="Share on Digg" target='_blank' href='http://digg.com/submit?phase=2%20&url=https://takebacksantacruz.org/home-data-county-evidence-used-stifle-community-discussion-syringe-service-program/&title=Home%20Is%20Where%20the%20Data%20Is%3A%20%20The%20County%20and%20the%20%22evidence%22%20used%20to%20stifle%20community%20discussion%20on%20the%20Syringe%20Service%20Program'> <div class='apss-icon-block clearfix'> <i class='fab fa-digg'></i> <span class='apss-social-text'>Share on Digg</span> <span class='apss-share'>Share</span> </div> </a> </div> </div>

Loading Facebook Comments ...

Stay Connected

EZ Fat Footer #3

This is Dynamik Widget Area. You can add content to this area by going to Appearance > Widgets in your WordPress Dashboard and adding new widgets to this area.

© 2015 Take Back Santa Cruz · Disclaimer · Privacy Policy · Sitemap | Site designed by Foxxr

Go to mobile version